Taunted to Death and Bullied Girl Kills Herself †Compare and sontrast Essay

The two articles, Taunted to Death and Bul stayd Girl Kills Herself, some(prenominal) report the same incident, which happened on Sunday 28th September 1997. The incident involved a youthful girl called Kelly Yeoman who killed herself. Taunted to Death is the report from a tabloid newspaper, The passing(a) sensation, and Bullied Girl Kills Herself is from a broadsheet newspaper, The defender. Despite twain articles reporting the same story, there are numerous authoritative goings in layout, content and style. There is an enormous difference in the presentational features of the articles. The headline of the tabloid newspaper is bold and large.Compared to the article, the headline is twice the size. It is create verbally in a white font on a black background to draw the accepters attention to the paper the effect of this is that they are converse out, whereas the protector headline is small in comparison to the article although it is still in bold type. The headlines conje cture the styles of the newspapers they both contrive bold, plain lettering to create a heavy(p)er impact on the reader. The difference between the two headlines is that the everyday confidential information headline Taunted to Death is placing the blame on some unrivalled and the withstander headline Bullied Girl Kills Herself is mutual.The free-and-easy Star has a greater impact because tabloid newspapers are approached differently in order to sensationalise the story, here Taunted to Death is headline grabbing. The first two paragraphs of these articles summarise the contents of the article. The free-and-easy Star tabloid Taunted to Death uses an ample amount of emotive raillerys to make the reader read on, hate campaign, whereas the protector is straight forward, telling the reader facts. Such as, Kelly was bullied about her weight, her parents were unemployed and she had inform to the school that she was being bullied.Such facts arent in the Daily Star. They are desi gned to evoke sympathy. The Guardian article is to a greater extent genuine but does use some emotive language, terrorised. The word terrorised suggests that Kelly was being frighten through violence. You can learn from the Guardian the gender and the age of the victim, 13 year-old girl, how she killed herself, found out of work yesterday in her bedroom after taking an overdose, a possible reason why she took this course of action, bullied at school and terrorised at foundation and the probable offenders responsible for the bullying, a mob of youths.Also, the Guardian shows the bigger picture as they raise social issues. The newspapers contain photographs of both Kelly and her mother, Julie. In the Daily Star, oneness of the photographs of Kelly is in juxtaposition with the headline it is in a block and is as large as the text. This has causes great effect and impact because she looks like a vulnerable victim and it shows who the article is about which induces empathy from the reader. The two photographs of Kelly, one in each newspaper, are visibly presenting her at different ages.In the Daily Star Kelly looks younger, she is besides wearing her Salvation Army uniform, this is to illustrate that she was an innocent young girl who looks very vulnerable. The Daily Star used this photograph because it is more personal. Also, Julie, Kellys mother, looks distraught in both articles this demonstrates the impact of her daughters premature death. In the Guardian there is a picture of Kellys mother, Julie, standing outside their home, it is ofttimes larger than the one in the Daily Star and is larger than the text.This photograph is used to illustrate their family home and show that they were just an average family. Julie looks distressed in this photograph but not as oftentimes as the one in the Daily Star. They live in a council house and people gent council houses with rough neighbourhoods. In the Guardian the photo of Kellys mother is less dramatic than th e one in the Daily Star. This is because the Daily Star is a sensational newspaper, they would run through had a range of photographs to choose from and they inflexible to choose these specific ones to match the style of the paper.The Guardian detracts a less emotive approach because it is nonpersonal and wants to remain neutral. The captions are longer in the Guardian whereas in the Daily Star they are giper and the word tearful is used to emphasise her mothers intense grief. The fonts are different in both articles, the Guardian is written in the same font throughout, with no sub-headings, whereas the Daily Star has one sub-heading, Hounded, which is written in bold and in a different font to make it stand out and affiliate the quotations.The word Hounded implies a chase and is metaphorical in the respect that it shows that she was bullied. Only two conversations are in bold and italic in the Daily Star. These two quotes are in bold because they are the roughly dramatic thi s is due to the fact that the newspaper wanted to highlight these quotations because they were from Kellys family, so they are focussing on the familys emotions in order to create a sensational approach to the story. The Daily Star mainly consists of quotations and conversations to be evidence for the reader to how people are feeling to clear up their sympathy.The quotations in the Daily Star are heart felt. My daughter has been hounded to death. I dont know why they did such things. By using the word hounded, Kellys father is implying that his daughter was pursued and harassed. The article is comprised of mainly quotations from family members, so the reader can see how they have had to cope with the loss of their daughter, and so they are sympathetic. The quotes are melodramatic. Ive had enough of this. Im going to take an overdose. Kelly said this to her mother.The Daily Star concentrates on the attack and the suicide and has used these quotations from family members to create a sensational account. The Guardian only has a a couple of(prenominal) quotes of family members and a great deal from outside agencies. Also, they are not as sympathetic but more forthright. This is unacceptable. They should make sure children are safe-how many more must we lose as a resolving power of bullying? This is a quotation from Pauline Hasler, director of the Anti-Bullying Campaign. This is included in the article because the Guardian is impersonal as it just wants to remain mutual.Although in the Guardian, one quotation from Kellys father Ivan, shows strong emotion. She was a bubbly, magic little angel who would do anything for anybody and I have lost her. This serves to remind the reader that she was only a little girl whose life was curtailed. The Guardian has included this quotation to show the seriousness of this issue and they have done so by using an emotive quotation. The Guardian tends to concentrate on the broader issues such as why Kelly was being bullied and what was being done by various agencies to resolve it leading up to her death.This is because the Guardian is unprejudiced and more formal. Derby City Council was due to meet the family and the police had been called out on several(prenominal) occasions. We were made aware of one incident that occurred on Friday and were intending to go round and see members of the family today. The Daily Star revolves more around the issue that she was dictated to kill herself, and not what was going on in Kellys life before she ended it. In this case the journalist of the Daily Star focuses on the attack of the house and the suicide, which are both dramatic events.The Daily Star concentrates more on the opinions of the family, which is shown in the use of quotations. The quotations are used to have an impact on the reader. The Guardian takes a more existent approach, telling the reader the events of Kellys life which may help to understand why she may have killed herself and raising issues for d ebate concerning the circumstances of her suicide such as whether or not she really was driven to kill herself and whether that can be classed as murder. The language used in both papers differs extremely.In the Guardian the fates are longer and the language is complicated. Some emotive words, such as, terrorised and taunted are used to gain sympathy from the reader, as it shows how she was separated out and that it was persistent. In the latest incident eggs, flour and butter were hurled at the house and abuse shouted at Kelly as she watched from an upstairs window. The emotive word in this sentence is hurled. It emphasises the malicious intention behind the attack and is more effective than using the word throwing. It suggests it was thrown and twisted with force and purpose.The preposition in this quote at stresses violence as opposed to being gentle. They also interrogate Kellys head teacher and the re-housing council in the Guardian. Their words speak of Kelly as a person and her ability. The Daily Star is full of emotive words this is because it is an opinionative article. Her distraught dad found the tragic 13 year-old dead in her bedroom when he went to wake her for school at 7. 50am. Distraught shows the fathers pain and suffering tragic conveys a terrible image and has a severe impact on the reader.These are just a few examples but the Daily Star has plenty more. The sentence bodily structure in the Guardian is complex. Pauline Hasler, director of the Anti-Bullying Campaign, which was formed in 1985, said many schools did not take a hard enough line against bullying. This is classified as a complex sentence. The sheath throughout this sentence is Anti-Bullying there are two objects, Pauline Hasler and schools in general. Punctuation joins three short statements together to form this complex sentence, whereas, the Daily Star tends to rely on open sentences.My daughter has been hounded to death. It is simple but striking. It is simple because it contains a subject a verb and an object. Another example of a simple sentence is Manslaughter charges could be brought if it is believed she was driven to kill herself. The Guardian appeals to the more educated person with a better reign of the English language, as it is a broadsheet newspaper. The vocabulary and style of language is more complex than a tabloid newspaper. The two newspapers are to suit different audiences and that is shown in the amount of fact and opinion in each article.The Daily Star is based on opinion whereas the Guardian takes a more factual approach. Although, they both try to grab the attention and sympathy from the reader. The Daily Star does this more successfully than the Guardian, the qualities of which lie in its broader range of facts and interviews with outside agencies which raise important issues beyond the immediate story of the suicide. general there is an element of class distinction which is related to the reader and their intellectual capabil ity.